9 Foods You Didn’t Know You Could Freeze

A person looks through the bread isle at a grocery store.
The bread section is pictured at Lucky's Market. Chris Zuppa/The Penny Hoarder

ScoreCard Research

When you throw away groceries you never used, you do more than waste food. You’re throwing money in the trash. Now, we aren’t saying this to shame you into eating something you don’t want. We’re here to tell you that you can save yourself from hemorrhaging cash by using something you likely already have: your freezer. To help you save on food, we compiled a list of items you might not realize you can freeze.

1. Herbs

Kaitlyn Blount harvests basil from her herb garden on her back porch in Tampa, Fla.
The Penny Hoarder

Fresh herbs can seriously elevate a meal. But what do you do when you have a bunch of leftover fresh basil and you’re burnt out on Italian food? Freeze it for later. Put whole bunches of herbs in a bag and label it and pop it in the freezer. For herbs you have already chopped, put them in ice cube trays with a little water and put the frozen herb cubes in a labeled bag. Looking for new ways to save? Try one (or all!) of The Penny Hoarder’s top picks for money-saving apps.

2. Milk

A man who works for Instacart walks down the aisle of a grocery store.
Photo courtesy of Instacart

If you’re a midwesterner who drank milk with every meal as a kid, you may already know you can freeze milk. But we all definitely know that once milk is bad, it’s bad. You don’t have to pour it down the drain if you won’t use up the gallon in time. You could also freeze this in an ice cube tray or in the container it comes in. If you’re freezing it in the container when it’s full, you’ll need to take a little out for when the milk expands. Then, just stick it in the fridge to thaw and give it a good shake occasionally, because there may be separation. If that’s too off putting for you to drink it, use it in recipes. Another money hack? Stop spending too much money on these five dumb things.

3. Eggs

Avocado toast is displayed four ways with eggs.
Photo courtesy of Feel Good Foodie

The key here is to not freeze the eggs in their shells (same concept as the milk — liquids expand when frozen). So, if you freeze them in the shells, they’ll crack and the thawing process will lead to a mess. However, you can crack them open, whisk them and freeze them in a container. You could even add some bell pepper and spinach and have a veggie scramble ready to go. Saving eggs that are about to go bad while also meal prepping your breakfast is a win-win. Outsmart inflation with these eight tips savvy shoppers know by heart.

4. Butter

safeway club card
The Penny Hoarder

If you forgot about the package of butter that got pushed to the back of the fridge and it’s about to go bad, don’t worry. It is a food you can freeze. You can freeze whole sticks or individual pats that you can use for smaller recipes. You can freeze salted or unsalted butter — you name it. Just put it in a freezer bag or an airtight container and look forward to a buttery future. Need some extra cash this season to fund the holidays? Try one of these 50 ways to make extra money this month.

5. Lemons and Limes

Preparing infused lemon drink
fcafotodigital

We see lots of frozen fruit in the freezer aisle at the store. This includes berries and tropical fruits like mango and pineapple. But you can actually freeze lemons and limes as well. If you want to freeze them whole, just give them a good wash and put them in a freezer bag. You can also freeze lemon and lime slices on a baking sheet before putting them in a bag in the freezer. This will work best if you want to save them for the juice, as they may get mushier. Love to play on your phone? These 22 legit games pay real money.

6. Cheese

ham and cheese skewers
Getty Images

The leftovers from that expensive charcuterie board you made aren’t getting any younger. But whether or not you can freeze cheese largely depends on the type. Hard and semi-hard cheeses freeze best. That’s cheese like cheddar, parmesan and mozzarella. Soft cheese like brie and blue cheese will go through a less than desirable transformation in the freezer. Stick your cheese in a freezer bag and push out as much air as possible then thaw when needed. Plan to use this cheese for cooking just in case you’re not a fan of the texture. Looking for another money-saving life hack? These companies give you food and other products for free.

7. Chicken Broth

Do you struggle cooking dinner during the busy work week? Why not try making this hummus and red pepper soup ahead of time?
Photo courtesy of Turnip the Oven

Chicken broth is great for cooking. But oftentimes you only need a small amount out of a larger container. If you’re not sure when you’ll need the rest again, put it in the freezer. You can do so in an ice cube tray for small amounts. Or, put it in a gallon freezer bag or mason jars (remember what we said about liquids freezing — don’t overfill either of these). Now you can make soup whenever the mood hits, or give a bump of flavor to a dish with one of the broth cubes. You could be wasting your hard-earned money. Here’s how to keep more of it.

8. Various Sauces

national spaghetti day
Shutterstock

Too much marinara or barbecue sauce after a big family dinner? Well, that’s a food you can freeze, too. Make sure any sauce that you’ve heated has fully cooled down. Then, put it in a plastic freezer bag or airtight container. You can even portion it out ahead of time so you don’t end up in the same situation you started in: too much sauce. Then, just thaw it in the fridge as you need it. Wrangle your grocery budget with these 25 tools and tricks to save you $100 (or more)!

9. Bread

The Penny Hoarder

Have you ever been excited to make toast or a sandwich and realized a fuzzy blue spot is staring at you as you go to take a slice of bread? Us too. If you’re worried your bread, whether bakery fresh or pre-sliced from the store, is about to go bad, freeze it. Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap before putting it in a freezer bag. You can take it all out and let it defrost on the counter or in the fridge. Or, if it’s already sliced or you don’t need very much, take however many slices you need and pop it in the toaster or leave it on the counter. It only takes minutes to thaw. Got $1,000 in your checking account? Make these money moves.

Are There Foods You Shouldn’t Freeze?

A woman slices cucumbers.
The Penny Hoarder

Knowing what food you can freeze is a great way to save money, cut down on food waste and plan your meals better. However, there are some things that just won’t hold up in your icy appliance. We already mentioned that soft cheese, which includes cottage cheese, shouldn’t go in the freezer. You also shouldn’t freeze most fried foods, hard boiled eggs and produce with high water content like cucumbers and watermelon. This new tool from The Penny Hoarder can help you save $500 on car insurance.